Battle of East & Middle Region foes
| Pope John Paul II | 1 |
| Baylor | 2 |
| FINAL | |
| Date | Result | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct. 22, 2022 | at Baylor | 2 | Pope John Paul II | 1 | |
| Oct. 17, 2020 | at Pope John Paul II | 1 | Baylor | 4 | |
| Oct. 19, 2019 | at Pope John Paul II | 3 | Baylor | 2 | |
| Oct. 4, 2018 | at Pope John Paul II | 2 | Baylor | 3 | |
| Aug. 29, 2017 | at Baylor | 4 | Pope John Paul II | 0 | |
| Oct. 11, 2016 | at Pope John Paul II | 0 | Baylor | 4 | |
| Oct. 12, 2015 | at Baylor | 2 | Pope John Paul II | 1 | |
| Oct. 21, 2014 | at Baylor | 3 | Pope John Paul II | 4 | |
| Oct. 14, 2014 | at Pope John Paul II | 0 | Baylor | 1 | |
| Sep. 7, 2013 | at Baylor | 0 | Pope John Paul II | 0 | |
| Oct. 16, 2012 | at Pope John Paul II | 0 | Baylor | 0 | |
| Sep. 28, 2011 | at Baylor | 6 | Pope John Paul II | 0 | |
| Oct. 14, 2010 | at Pope John Paul II | 0 | Baylor | 0 | |
| Nov. 5, 2009 | at Baylor | 2 | Pope John Paul II | 1 | |
| Oct. 15, 2009 | at Baylor | 1 | Pope John Paul II | 1 | |
| Oct. 25, 2008 | at Pope John Paul II | 2 | Baylor | 3 | |
| Aug. 29, 2008 | at Baylor | 0 | Pope John Paul II | 0 | |
| Sep. 7, 2007 | at Pope John Paul II | 1 | Baylor | 2 | |