| Pope John Paul II | 1 |
| St. Agnes Academy | 2 |
| FINAL | |
| Date | Result | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct. 29, 2011 | at St. Agnes Academy | 3 | Pope John Paul II | 1 | |
| Nov. 4, 2010 | at St. Agnes Academy | 2 | Pope John Paul II | 1 | |
| Sep. 10, 2010 | at St. Agnes Academy | 0 | Pope John Paul II | 0 | |
| Sep. 18, 2009 | at Pope John Paul II | 2 | St. Agnes Academy | 2 | |
| Nov. 1, 2008 | at Pope John Paul II | 1 | St. Agnes Academy | 0 | |