| Date |
Result |
| Apr. 24, 2019 |
 |
at Pope John Paul II (TN) | 0 |
Baylor (TN) | 15 |
| Apr. 30, 2018 |
 |
at Baylor (TN) | 14 |
Pope John Paul II (TN) | 4 |
| May. 17, 2017 |
 |
at Baylor (TN) | 16 |
Pope John Paul II (TN) | 3 |
| May. 17, 2017 |
 |
at Baylor (TN) | 10 |
Pope John Paul II (TN) | 0 |
| Mar. 31, 2017 |
 |
at Pope John Paul II (TN) | 0 |
Baylor (TN) | 21 |
| May. 7, 2016 |
 |
at Baylor (TN) | 15 |
Pope John Paul II (TN) | 1 |
| Apr. 17, 2015 |
 |
at Pope John Paul II (TN) | 4 |
Baylor (TN) | 7 |
| May. 22, 2014 |
 |
at Pope John Paul II (TN) | 1 |
Baylor (TN) | 10 |
| May. 3, 2014 |
 |
at Baylor (TN) | 10 |
Pope John Paul II (TN) | 1 |
| Mar. 23, 2013 |
 |
at Pope John Paul II (TN) | 4 |
Baylor (TN) | 3 |
| May. 4, 2012 |
 |
at Baylor (TN) | 17 |
Pope John Paul II (TN) | 1 |
| May. 25, 2011 |
 |
at Pope John Paul II (TN) | 0 |
Baylor (TN) | 9 |
| Apr. 8, 2011 |
 |
at Pope John Paul II (TN) | 2 |
Baylor (TN) | 13 |
| May. 25, 2007 |
 |
at Baylor (TN) | 0 |
Pope John Paul II (TN) | 1 |
| May. 22, 2007 |
 |
at Pope John Paul II (TN) | 3 |
Baylor (TN) | 2 |
| May. 25, 2005 |
 |
at Pope John Paul II (TN) | 0 |
Baylor (TN) | 14 |