| Date | Result | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr. 24, 2012 | at Davidson Academy (TN) | 3 | St. Andrew's-Sewanee (TN) | 0 | |
| Apr. 21, 2011 | at St. Andrew's-Sewanee (TN) | 4 | Davidson Academy (TN) | 3 | |
| Apr. 22, 2010 | at Davidson Academy (TN) | 2 | St. Andrew's-Sewanee (TN) | 2 | |
| Apr. 23, 2009 | at St. Andrew's-Sewanee (TN) | 2 | Davidson Academy (TN) | 1 | |
| Apr. 2, 2009 | at Davidson Academy (TN) | 4 | St. Andrew's-Sewanee (TN) | 2 | |
| May. 5, 2008 | at Davidson Academy (TN) | 2 | St. Andrew's-Sewanee (TN) | 1 | |
| Apr. 22, 2008 | at St. Andrew's-Sewanee (TN) | 4 | Davidson Academy (TN) | 1 | |
| Apr. 1, 2008 | at Davidson Academy (TN) | 1 | St. Andrew's-Sewanee (TN) | 2 | |